A Pebble on the Ocean Shore

on Wayne Brown's escapades

I do not know Wayne Brown personally. I do not live in Auckland. I have no particular interest or investment in Wayne Brown's actions as mayor of Auckland. I can only write about Wayne Brown as the character who appears in the news as Mayor of Auckland, and my opinion of him is based purely on that. I may well have completely misread the man. But, as Mayor of Auckland, he's in the news a lot, and he seems to be on a roll this week.

So Wayne Brown has paid a little visit to China and has said some things that have some people all hot under the collar, particularly the US ambassador.

Mr Brown went on a visit to China, and he was quite impressed with the place. Fair enough. Many people have that reaction. Then he came back and said some things that reflect how impressed he was, and that also suggest that perhaps he didn't do terribly much critical thinking about what he saw. Again, this is a fairly common phenomenon. Of course, when ordinary people do this, nobody cares. But when the mayor of the country's biggest city does this, it gets in the news.

So what did he say? Radio New Zealand reports that he told Stuff:

"It's an unfathomable system… and look at the election in America… produced a sort of non-working government. Europe hasn't had a good election for years," he told Stuff.

"Democracy's had its day. It's time for something else, really."

Which I think means that in addition to New Zealand's current election having still not achieved a result thanks to the two traditional major parties having failed to inspire much confidence, there's been a few other elections around the world that have produced a result he disapproves of.

From the same article:

He praised China's approach to economic growth, saying it allowed businesses to fail whereas in New Zealand they can be propped up, citing Fletcher Building as an example.

So he does not understand what he saw in China, nor how things work in the rest of the world. "Too big to fail" is not a concept unique to New Zealand, nor is it something foreign to China.

And then he makes comments about MMP as it has been implemented in New Zealand that suggest he doesn't really understand how it works, but I'll leave that for somebody else.

Then the US ambassador sees this and decides to ignore the usual diplomatic protocol and weigh in. I did finally find a link to his reaction to Mr Brown, but it is on a social media platform I'd prefer not to support1. I'll leave the commentary on diplomatic protocol to others. I note the ambassador's response included this:

The United States and New Zealand didn’t build two successful democracies by deciding that giving people a say was too much trouble.

Well, he's half right. The United States of America2 has not built a successful democracy. Not only that, but the USA's founding fathers decided that in fact giving people a say was a bit much trouble, so they set up the electoral college to put a limit on just how much say the Great Unwashed could have.

Some people have been calling Mr Brown a "useful idiot" for his comments to Chinese media during a visit. I wasn't convinced, at first. This article on Newsroom says he was talking to CCTV about his admiration for Xi Jinping. I strongly suspect that was purely for domestic consumption - Chinese media telling Chinese punters about this big, important, foreign politician being all impressed by China and Xi Jinping. No different to New Zealand media going all gushy every time some famous foreigner says something nice about our remote islands. But then he was talking to CGTN, and that is definitely for foreign consumption. So the "useful idiot" charge seems to fit.

But then again, the "useful idiot" phenomenon is not really restricted to communist countries. There are plenty out there singing the praises of the USA and Trump, playing an identical role for a different kind of regime. I was wondering if perhaps Anna Fifield could be labelled a "useful idiot" herself, but then Newsroom went and reprinted her substack on this kerfuffle. I'm glad, because that's another platform I'd prefer not to link to3. Anyways, although the article does stress some of the negative things that have been happening in China, she also mentions some of the negative things happening in the USA, and the full article is considerably more balanced than the snippets quoted could've suggested, so fair enough.

Well, and then Mr Brown has gone and tried to clarify his comments, saying it was all about trade, and differences between Auckland and Wellington. And he does manage to make a good point or two, for example, mentioning China Eastern Airlines' Shanghai-Auckland-Buenos Aires route, or the complexity of visas. But it all feels very weak.

This same article then reports on Phil Goff's reaction to Mr Brown's comments on New Zealand's place in Five Eyes. I think Mr Brown may have accidentally almost had half a point to make in questioning whether New Zealand should remain in Five Eyes. Given the political tendencies in the USA and UK of late, we really need to think very hard about which side of history we want to be on, and whether throwing in with our traditional Imperial Overlords is really all that good an idea. Phil Goff seems to think Five Eyes is good for New Zealand - and it certainly should get us access to a lot more intelligence than we'd be able to gather on our own. But do we really want to associate with a country that arrests grannies for opposing genocide? Or a country that's gone openly fascist?4 But Phil Goff does make a couple of very good points:

"I've been both mayor and foreign minister. That's not part of your brief as mayor of Auckland when you go to a country that has political differences with New Zealand, albeit a close trading partner, to make comments about our security arrangements. That's a role for the foreign minister."

and:

He said Brown needed to focus on serving the people of Auckland.

"I thought Brown was starting to get to grips with his role and saying a number of things I agreed with. These comments were a total throwback to the grumpy old man comments he had a bit of a reputation for before.

"I don't think it has done him any good, and it certainly hasn't done New Zealand any good."

Before I continue, I want to emphasise what I wrote at the very start, that I do not know Wayne Brown personally. I do not live in Auckland. I have no particular interest or investment in Wayne Brown's actions as mayor of Auckland. I can only write about Wayne Brown as the character who appears in the news as Mayor of Auckland, and my opinion of him is based purely on that. I may well have completely misread the man.

The impression I have of Wayne Brown is that he is a grumpy old man who has enjoyed some success in life, but bumbles along without much critical thinking, running things on vibes and reckons, not particularly concerned about facts or evidence. This whole episode has served to reinforce that impression. I think this is a good example of why we need to pay as much attention to local politics as we do national politics - we'd probably get a better quality of local government if would-be mayors were forced to persuade as many people of their virtues as would-be MPs. But that's a different rant for a different time.

If we have another look at that Newsroom article linked above about Mr Brown praising Xi Jinping on CCTV and scroll down to near the end, there's a wee reminder of something Newsroom discovered and reported in October last year:

Newsroom revealed in October 2025 that $2000 a month was being paid to Jean Wen, the office manager for Fuh Wah International Group, the Beijing-based developer of Auckland’s five-star waterfront Park Hyatt Hotel.

The link Newsroom has in that sentence goes to a Google search. Ugh. I believe this is the article referred to.

If I were an Auckland ratepayer, I would be concerned about this. Especially considering Newsroom had to go to the Ombudsman to get the information requested. And then:

Mayoral office accounts show that payment this year has doubled to $4000 a month.

I guess if Shane Jones were mayor of Auckland then the corruption would be crass, vulgar, and right out in the open. But Mr Brown is mayor of Auckland, and what we have is a situation that should be raising eyebrows and getting people investigating.

Now, having written all of that, did Wayne Brown get anything right?

Yes, in fact, he did.

There is a lot happening in China that New Zealand could and should learn from. I would start with the government investment in public transport, be it subway systems, light rail, and electric buses in cities, and an amazing rail network, including high-speed trains, between cities. There's also the government pushing electric vehicles, and massive investment in renewable energy. And I understand why Mr Brown was so impressed by the state of China's economy. Last time I was in China everybody was complaining about the tough economy, and I still hear that from the wife's friends and family on occasion, but I was looking around thinking, "Geez, if this is a tough economy, then I'd much rather be doing it tough in China than in New Zealand". I was only there for a month, and there's not much one can reasonably say based on a fleeting visit, even when one does speak and read the language, but what I saw, what people were describing as "tough", looked like the kind of economy we here in Aotearoa can only dream of. Comparing that with Wellington now after three years of the National-ACT-NZFirst Coalition of Chaos deliberately trashing the place is like....

....well, I understand why Wayne Brown is so impressed with China.

  1. because somebody will ask: Fascism is bad and should not be supported, that's why.↩

  2. I want to be as precise as possible because I do not wish to drag the United Mexican States, or any other united states into this mess.↩

  3. there's been enough reported about Substack's platforming of nazis and other assorted fascists. So footnote 1 above, see also.↩

  4. I must say that the recent US midterms do give reason to hope that the American people might be able to steer their country back towards civilisation, but the current regime is still in power, and there's an awful lot of work to be done before we can trust the USA again.↩