are we sick of politics? or politicians? or both?
Radio NZ has an article today headlined Are New Zealanders sick of politics- or sick of politicians?. In it a few experts pontificate on what has gone wrong in New Zealand politics and why people are less engaged. The experts highlight some real problems, and I don't disagree with any of them.
But for me, there are a few stand-out issues.
It starts at the top. Our political, business, and media leaders seem absolutely determined to copy every stupid thing America does.
To be clear, the United States of America is not all bad. There's plenty of good in America, even under the current regime - see the recent mid-term election results, for example. Or remember that Woody Guthrie, Joan Baez, Bruce Springtseen, Tom Morello, and Dolly Parton are (or were) all American.
However, there are aspects of American political and media culture that New Zealand's excuse for leadership seems determined to import. The Radio NZ article dabbles in this - negative campaigning, personality-based media coverage, and so on. But it doesn't go far enough. We had an election campaign in which the media seemed to think it'd be a good idea to portray the election as a choice between either Christopher Luxon or Chris Hipkins. Nevermind that we do not elect presidents, nor do we vote for prime ministers. I got to vote either for or against Chris Hipkins because I live in the Remutaka electorate and he is my local MP. I had the option of voting for him to continue as my local MP. The election was not a race between the two Chrises with the other party leaders playing the plucky underdogs who have no real chance of election. As always, we voted for who we want as our local MP, and for which party we believe would be best in government. As always, the results mean the parties elected to parliament will have to sit down and figure out a coalition commanding a majority of seats in parliament. And those negotiations will determine who will become prime minister.
We would have been much better served if our media leaders chose to report our politics as they are in our system that is in force here in Aotearoa rather than based on their bizarre fever dreams of how things are in America.
Likewise our politicians. Run campaigns to suit the system we have. More importantly, leave the negative campaigning, attack ads, and culture war bullshit in America. Why they hell have they been trying to import that shit here? We don't need it, it doesn't help anyone, and it's clearly driving a lot of good people away while making bad people feel empowered to behave badly.
Our political and media leaders have the power to choose to campaign and report in positive, constructive, cooperative ways. Our politicians can tell us what they stand for and what they will do for us rather than play on peoples' fears and insecurities. Our media has the power to choose to report in depth on policies rather than personalities, to inform rather than bamboozle with superficial razzle-dazzle and puerile "gotcha" games. And the choices they make will have a flow on effect into how people engage.
And that brings me to a key element: Our choices. Social media isn't eroding our attention spans, literacy, or numeracy. We are. Nobody is forcing us on to Facebook, Twitter, or Tik Tok, and we are free to leave those platforms. If we choose to remain on Facebook, Twitter, or Tik Tok, we can choose not to engage in any of the negativity. Ignore the clickbait, ignore the extremists trying to stoke hatred, follow the good people engaging in good faith, play the algorithm so that it feeds you good stuff.
Or stay away from corporate social media entirely, it is your choice.
Of course, non-corporate social media, be it the fediverse or whatever, is still filled with people, so has all the same problems, just without the algorithm. But the same principle applies. Stumble across a neo-nazi on Mastodon? Block them, move on. Stumble across somebody posting about the community garden they're running? Follow them, engage. Again, it is your choice.
None of us needs to get dragged in to the tribalistic bullshit the worse people in politics and the media (traditional and social) are pushing.
We are free to opt out of that nonsense and opt in to working together to make this world better.
Now, as for the tribalism: A big bugbear for me at the moment is the National and Labour parties. They seem to be stuck in a First Past the Post mindset, where they still believe they are the "major parties", that the government should be lead by one or the other of them, that the "minor parties" are there to prop their governments up, and that they are each other's enemy.
It's been thirty years already! Thirty years since we ditched FPP and moved to MMP.
It is long since time they dropped the old FPP attitudes and started playing MMP honestly. Labour and National have a lot in common and they could easily solve the current political impasse by ditching the bullshit tribalism and going into coalition together. They are capable of figuring out a way for them to cooperate with each other.
Imagine how that would change Aotearoa's political scene?